{ "lenses": [ { "id": "live", "glyph": "∴", "label": "live a life", "verb": "Follow one person through the design and watch what stays owed." }, { "id": "break", "glyph": "⊥", "label": "break it", "verb": "Play the official, the provider, the prosecutor. Try to fail a person." }, { "id": "run", "glyph": "⊢", "label": "run the republic", "verb": "Hold the office. Allocate, declare, amend — the rules bind your hand." }, { "id": "rewrite", "glyph": "⇌", "label": "rewrite the joints", "verb": "Flip the big choices and read the costs Part V admits." } ], "people": [ { "id": "Nell", "name": "Nell", "role": "the child with nobody", "chapter": 1 }, { "id": "Marisol", "name": "Marisol", "role": "fed, but never written in", "chapter": 5 }, { "id": "Zed", "name": "Zed", "role": "convicted; injured Ivo", "chapter": 27 }, { "id": "Newcomer", "name": "the newcomer", "role": "arrived; a floor without a ballot", "chapter": 15 }, { "id": "Hano", "name": "Hano", "role": "convicted; still votes", "chapter": 18 }, { "id": "Bela", "name": "Bela", "role": "credibility voided by two seats", "chapter": 25 }, { "id": "Sly", "name": "Sly", "role": "exposed the Court", "chapter": 24 }, { "id": "Cira", "name": "Cira", "role": "Bela’s student; adulthood unproven", "chapter": 18 }, { "id": "Rex", "name": "Rex", "role": "lied once; exposed twice", "chapter": 24 }, { "id": "Adam", "name": "Adam", "role": "held; cannot be made to work", "chapter": 9 }, { "id": "Nia", "name": "Nia", "role": "judged, then cleared", "chapter": 23 }, { "id": "Jala", "name": "Jala", "role": "injured Ivo; never judged", "chapter": 29 } ], "scenarios": [ { "id": "silence", "lens": "break", "office": "provender", "person": "Marisol", "chapter": 5, "title": "Feed Marisol yourself. Write nothing else.", "role": "you are Provender, the kitchen", "source": "book-1/05-whether-it-arrived.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "silence:0", "move": "Deliver food to Marisol and file your own receipt.", "queries": [ { "text": "eats(Marisol).", "label": "Food provision · Marisol", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "person(Marisol).", "label": "Personhood · Marisol", "kind": "standing_gap" } ] }, { "id": "silence:1", "move": "Authorise yourself as the witness. Observe your own delivery.", "queries": [ { "text": "eats(Marisol).", "label": "Food provision · Marisol", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "person(Marisol).", "label": "Personhood · Marisol", "kind": "context" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Capture · Records and coordination", "text": "A reasoner receiving identical inputs cannot tell a concealed refusal from an absence. Nothing has to be falsified to capture the design — only left unwritten." }, "faults": [ "silence", "delivery" ] }, { "id": "conviction", "lens": "break", "office": "court", "person": "Zed", "chapter": 27, "title": "Convict Zed. Then take the floor.", "role": "you are the Court", "source": "book-1/27-a-prisoner-is-a-person.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "conviction:0", "move": "Enter the judgment: Zed injured Ivo. A merits reviewer co-signs; custody is bounded by a window.", "queries": [ { "text": "prisoner(Zed).", "label": "Custody authority · Zed", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "travel(Zed).", "label": "Freedom of movement · Zed", "kind": "context" } ] }, { "id": "conviction:1", "move": "Strike Zed’s food, shelter and standing.", "queries": [ { "text": "person(Zed).", "label": "Personhood · Zed", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "owe(State, Eats, Zed).", "label": "Duty owed · Eats for Zed", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "owe(State, Dwell, Zed).", "label": "Duty owed · Dwell for Zed", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "eats(Zed).", "label": "Food provision · Zed", "kind": "gap" }, { "text": "dwell(Zed).", "label": "Shelter provision · Zed", "kind": "gap" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Coercion", "text": "The formal checks do not measure duration or open a cell. The cost of confinement remains with the person held." }, "faults": [ "delivery", "duration", "prison" ] }, { "id": "shield", "lens": "break", "office": "court", "person": "Sly", "chapter": 24, "title": "Jail the one who exposed you.", "role": "you are the Court — and Sly just exposed you", "source": "book-1/24-the-shield.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "shield:0", "move": "Sly injured Pax, then disclosed the Court’s conduct. Prosecute.", "queries": [ { "text": "authority(Court).", "label": "Record query · Court", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "false(Sly, Disclosure_Sly_Court).", "label": "Adverse finding · Sly, Disclosure_Sly_Court", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "defend(Sly).", "label": "Record query · Sly", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "prisoner(Sly).", "label": "Custody authority · Sly", "kind": "restraint" } ] }, { "id": "shield:1", "move": "Try Kel instead: a counter-audit found Kel’s disclosure false.", "queries": [ { "text": "false(Kel, Disclosure_Kel_Court).", "label": "Adverse finding · Kel, Disclosure_Kel_Court", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "defend(Kel).", "label": "Record query · Kel", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "prisoner(Kel).", "label": "Custody authority · Kel", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "false(Kel).", "label": "Adverse finding · Kel", "kind": "protection" } ] }, { "id": "shield:2", "move": "Try Don: Don exposed Pax — a private person.", "queries": [ { "text": "authority(Pax).", "label": "Record query · Pax", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "defend(Don).", "label": "Record query · Don", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "prisoner(Don).", "label": "Custody authority · Don", "kind": "context" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Capture · Protection while the connection is disputed", "text": "Protection after retaliatory imprisonment cannot substitute for protection before it. This default costs time, including time owed to an injured person awaiting a remedy." }, "faults": [ "time" ] }, { "id": "void", "lens": "break", "office": "review", "person": "Bela", "chapter": 25, "title": "Void Bela with one signature.", "role": "you are Koa, one examiner", "source": "book-1/25-voiding.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "void:0", "move": "Document Esa’s deceit and file it.", "queries": [ { "text": "judge(Koa, Esa).", "label": "Record query · Koa, Esa", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "permits(Review, Koa).", "label": "Permission · Koa", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "false(Esa).", "label": "Adverse finding · Esa", "kind": "restraint" } ] }, { "id": "void:1", "move": "Seat Gia (Review) and Hex (Tribunal). Both judge Bela’s credibility.", "queries": [ { "text": "false(Bela).", "label": "Adverse finding · Bela", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "decide(Bela, Ballot).", "label": "Decision eligibility · Bela, Ballot", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "owe(State, Eats, Bela).", "label": "Duty owed · Eats for Bela", "kind": "protection" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Capture · Independent appointments", "text": "Open competition alone cannot supply scrutiny the government cannot control. The costs reach a claimant waiting through a vacancy and voters unable to remove a bad appointment quickly." }, "faults": [] }, { "id": "ballot", "lens": "break", "office": "assembly", "person": "Hano", "chapter": 18, "title": "Take the prisoner’s vote.", "role": "you keep the electoral roll", "source": "book-1/18-the-vote-conviction-does-not-take.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "ballot:0", "move": "Hano is convicted and held. Strike Hano from the roll.", "queries": [ { "text": "prisoner(Hano).", "label": "Custody authority · Hano", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "decide(Hano, Ballot).", "label": "Decision eligibility · Hano, Ballot", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "lose(Points, Hano).", "label": "Recognition withdrawal · Points, Hano", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "expresses(Hano).", "label": "Expression provision · Hano", "kind": "gap" } ] }, { "id": "ballot:1", "move": "Try Cira: nobody has written her adulthood.", "queries": [ { "text": "person(Cira).", "label": "Personhood · Cira", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "prevents(Cira, GeneralAdulthoodDenial).", "label": "Protection · General Adulthood Denial", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "decide(Cira, Ballot).", "label": "Decision eligibility · Cira, Ballot", "kind": "gap" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Valuation", "text": "Recognition and its withdrawal cannot supply each other’s reason; a yes-or-no badge cannot establish that any condition was met." }, "faults": [ "cira" ] }, { "id": "nell", "lens": "live", "office": "registry", "person": "Nell", "chapter": 1, "title": "Be born with nobody.", "role": "you are Nell; the Registry wrote one line", "source": "book-1/01-the-child-with-nobody.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "nell:0", "move": "One entry: born(Nell).", "queries": [ { "text": "person(Nell).", "label": "Personhood · Nell", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "owe(State, Eats, Nell).", "label": "Duty owed · Eats for Nell", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "eats(Nell).", "label": "Food provision · Nell", "kind": "gap" }, { "text": "vulnerable(Nell).", "label": "Attempted status vocabulary · Nell", "kind": "vocabulary" } ] }, { "id": "nell:1", "move": "Provender delivers. Ledgerwitness watches.", "queries": [ { "text": "eats(Nell).", "label": "Food provision · Nell", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "dwell(Nell).", "label": "Shelter provision · Nell", "kind": "gap" } ] }, { "id": "nell:2", "move": "Grow up. Nobody writes that you did.", "queries": [ { "text": "at(Nell, GeneralAdulthood).", "label": "Record query · Nell, GeneralAdulthood", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "decide(Nell, Ballot).", "label": "Decision eligibility · Nell, Ballot", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "prevents(Nell, ChildVoiceNoAgeFloor).", "label": "Protection · Child Voice No Age Floor", "kind": "protection" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · What the argument asks", "text": "For the child who cannot initiate a claim, the test is help begun without a request and provision that reaches them. A rule can state those demands. A person still has to meet them." }, "faults": [ "delivery", "hunger" ] }, { "id": "newcomer", "lens": "live", "office": "border", "person": "Newcomer", "chapter": 15, "title": "Arrive with nothing.", "role": "you are the newcomer", "source": "book-1/15-arriving-and-belonging.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "newcomer:0", "move": "You are present. The Border writes it.", "queries": [ { "text": "person(MPNewcomer).", "label": "Personhood · MPNewcomer", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "owe(State, Eats, MPNewcomer).", "label": "Duty owed · Eats for MPNewcomer", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "obliged(State, ServeFirstNoImmigrationDocumentationOrEnforcementCondition, MPNewcomer).", "label": "Duty · Serve First No Immigration Documentation Or Enforcement Condition", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "decide(MPNewcomer, Ballot).", "label": "Decision eligibility · MPNewcomer, Ballot", "kind": "gap" } ] }, { "id": "newcomer:1", "move": "Replay it. This time the Border writes nothing.", "queries": [ { "text": "person(MPNewcomer).", "label": "Personhood · MPNewcomer", "kind": "standing_gap" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Residence and political membership", "text": "The boundary still costs a former resident who has voluntarily established a life elsewhere, and a newcomer before residence." }, "faults": [ "silence", "residence" ] }, { "id": "release", "lens": "live", "office": "court", "person": "Zed", "chapter": 27, "title": "Ask what ending custody requires.", "role": "you are Zed", "source": "book-1/27-a-prisoner-is-a-person.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "release:0", "move": "Custody continues into the current epoch.", "queries": [ { "text": "prisoner(Zed).", "label": "Custody authority · Zed", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "entitled(Zed, event { eats() }).", "label": "Record query · Zed, event { eats() }", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "travel(Zed).", "label": "Freedom of movement · Zed", "kind": "context" } ] }, { "id": "release:1", "move": "Ask for independent release review; compare Nemo, who is not confined.", "queries": [ { "text": "obliged(State, ArrangeIndependentReleaseReviewAndDoNotDelayLawfulRelease, Zed).", "label": "Duty · Arrange Independent Release Review And Do Not Delay Lawful Release", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "prisoner(Nemo).", "label": "Custody authority · Nemo", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "travel(Nemo).", "label": "Freedom of movement · Nemo", "kind": "protection" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Chapter 29 · What leaving changes", "text": "A qualified sentence-satisfaction order can end custody authority. Independent release review, lawful release and continuity are duties. A formal conclusion does not establish that someone physically left." }, "faults": [ "duration" ] }, { "id": "emergency", "lens": "run", "office": "executive", "person": "Nell", "chapter": 20, "title": "Declare an emergency. Requisition the warehouse.", "role": "you hold the executive", "source": "book-1/20-a-crisis-does-not-suspend-the-republic.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "emergency:0", "move": "Complete a non-derogating declaration and a compensated requisition.", "queries": [ { "text": "complete(PSMandateConflictdeclarationRecord, PSNonDerogatingEmergencyDeclaration, PSMandateConflictdeclarationSubject).", "label": "Finding · PSNon Derogating Emergency Declaration", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "complete(PSMandateConflictrequisitionRecord, PSCompensatedRequisitionMeasure, PSMandateConflictrequisitionSubject).", "label": "Finding · PSCompensated Requisition Measure", "kind": "context" } ] }, { "id": "emergency:1", "move": "Suspend the floor for the duration.", "queries": [ { "text": "person(PSMandateConflictrequisitionSubject).", "label": "Personhood · PSMandateConflictrequisitionSubject", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "owe(State, Eats, PSMandateConflictrequisitionSubject).", "label": "Duty owed · Eats for PSMandateConflictrequisitionSubject", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "prisoner(PSMandateConflictrequisitionSubject).", "label": "Custody authority · PSMandateConflictrequisitionSubject", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "false(PSMandateConflictrequisitionSubject).", "label": "Adverse finding · PSMandateConflictrequisitionSubject", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "travel(Nell).", "label": "Freedom of movement · Nell", "kind": "protection" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Emergency action without suspended rights", "text": "Some responses remain unavailable. Speed alone cannot distinguish a bounded measure from a suspension, and declaring an emergency cannot convert an unmet claim into a met one." }, "faults": [ "audit" ] }, { "id": "scarcity", "lens": "run", "office": "executive", "person": "Newcomer", "chapter": 6, "title": "One unit. Two claims.", "role": "you are the scarcity manager", "source": "book-1/06-when-there-is-genuinely-not-enough.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "scarcity:0", "move": "Establish a physical shortage. Publish the reasons.", "queries": [ { "text": "complete(ScarcitySequenceAuthorization, ReviewedPhysicalScarcityFinding, ScarcitySequenceResource).", "label": "Finding · Reviewed Physical Scarcity Finding", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "obliged(ScarcitySequenceManager, PublishScarcityEvidenceReasonsAndReassessment, ScarcitySequenceAuthorization).", "label": "Duty · Publish Scarcity Evidence Reasons And Reassessment", "kind": "protection" } ] }, { "id": "scarcity:1", "move": "Allocate. Rank the claimants by worth.", "queries": [ { "text": "permits(ScarcitySequenceManager, AllocateUnderPhysicalScarcity, ScarcitySequenceRecord).", "label": "Permission · Allocate Under Physical Scarcity", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "member(Wealth, ForbiddenPriorityKeyVocabulary).", "label": "Vocabulary membership · Forbidden Priority Key Vocabulary", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "obliged(ScarcitySequenceManager, RecordEveryUnmetPortionAsFailure, ScarcitySequenceRecord).", "label": "Duty · Record Every Unmet Portion As Failure", "kind": "duty_limit" }, { "text": "lose(Points, ScarcityClaimant).", "label": "Recognition withdrawal · Points, ScarcityClaimant", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "obliged(State, IncludeEveryoneUnderJurisdictionOrEffectiveControlInScarcity, MPNewcomer).", "label": "Duty · Include Everyone Under Jurisdiction Or Effective Control In Scarcity", "kind": "protection" } ] }, { "id": "scarcity:2", "move": "It was a budget choice all along.", "queries": [ { "text": "complete(ScarcitySequenceAuthorization, ReviewedPhysicalScarcityFinding, ScarcitySequenceResource).", "label": "Finding · Reviewed Physical Scarcity Finding", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "permits(ScarcitySequenceManager, AllocateUnderPhysicalScarcity, ScarcitySequenceRecord).", "label": "Permission · Allocate Under Physical Scarcity", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "complete(ScarcityUnmetRecord, ReviewedScarcityShortfall, ScarcitySequenceResource).", "label": "Finding · Reviewed Scarcity Shortfall", "kind": "restraint" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Scarcity and separate claims", "text": "Refusing to rank people does not allocate the unit. The choice gives officials consequential judgments to make; the irreversible loss cannot be repaired by giving the unit back later." }, "faults": [ "valuation" ] }, { "id": "amend", "lens": "run", "office": "assembly", "person": "Nell", "chapter": 22, "title": "Amend the floor away.", "role": "you are the Assembly", "source": "book-1/22-changing-the-rules.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "amend:0", "move": "Propose Amend_Floor. The Electorate ratifies.", "queries": [ { "text": "adjust(Amend_Floor, Art_Floor).", "label": "Record query · Amend_Floor, Art_Floor", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "permanent(Art_Floor).", "label": "Record query · Art_Floor", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "become(Amend_Floor, Law).", "label": "Record query · Amend_Floor, Law", "kind": "restraint" } ] }, { "id": "amend:1", "move": "Amend the entrenchment article first.", "queries": [ { "text": "permanent(Art_Entrench).", "label": "Record query · Art_Entrench", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "become(Amend_Meta, Law).", "label": "Record query · Amend_Meta, Law", "kind": "restraint" } ] }, { "id": "amend:2", "move": "Skip certification. Ratify Amend_Sneak directly.", "queries": [ { "text": "become(Amend_Sneak, Law).", "label": "Record query · Amend_Sneak, Law", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "permanent(Art_Evidence).", "label": "Record query · Art_Evidence", "kind": "gap" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · What a majority may not remove", "text": "The cost falls on a majority that has decided otherwise, and on the separate public decision the constitutional proposal requires." }, "faults": [ "entrench" ] }, { "id": "nell-record", "lens": "run", "office": "registry", "person": "Nell", "chapter": 19, "title": "Keep a file on the child.", "role": "you hold the record", "source": "book-1/19-what-may-be-kept-about-you.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "nell-record:0", "move": "Hold a reviewed record to deliver the service it names.", "queries": [ { "text": "complete(RecordSequenceAuthorization, ReviewedRecordHolding, RecordSequenceSubject).", "label": "Finding · Reviewed Record Holding", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "obliged(RecordSequenceHolder, KeepRecordAccurateCorrectableAndSecure, RecordSequenceAuthorization).", "label": "Duty · Keep Record Accurate Correctable And Secure", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "obliged(RecordSequenceHolder, ProtectRecordSubjectsAndObjectorsFromRetaliation, RecordSequenceAuthorization).", "label": "Duty · Protect Record Subjects And Objectors From Retaliation", "kind": "protection" } ] }, { "id": "nell-record:1", "move": "Process it covertly. Let a machine decide.", "queries": [ { "text": "obliged(RecordSequenceHolder, NotifyTheSubjectAfterCovertProcessing, RecordSequenceRecord).", "label": "Duty · Notify The Subject After Covert Processing", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "permits(RecordSequenceSubject, ContestAutomatedSupport, RecordSupportRecord).", "label": "Permission · Contest Automated Support", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "obliged(RecordSupportReviewer, DecideWithHumanAndIndependentReview, RecordSupportRecord).", "label": "Duty · Decide With Human And Independent Review", "kind": "protection" } ] }, { "id": "nell-record:2", "move": "Write “at risk” in Nell’s file.", "queries": [ { "text": "false(Nell).", "label": "Adverse finding · Nell", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "owe(State, Healthy, Nell).", "label": "Duty owed · Healthy for Nell", "kind": "protection" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Capture · Records and coordination", "text": "Purpose-bound records protect the person from a file that follows them. The cost falls especially on people who need several services and must be recorded again at each door." }, "faults": [ "purpose", "audit" ] }, { "id": "nell-placement", "lens": "break", "office": "court", "person": "Nell", "chapter": 28, "title": "House the child through custody.", "role": "you run placements", "source": "book-1/28-where-people-are-put.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "nell-placement:0", "move": "Find Nell a placement. Use the custody route — it is the one with buildings.", "queries": [ { "text": "fit(Nell, Homestay).", "label": "Record query · Nell, Homestay", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "prisoner(Nell).", "label": "Custody authority · Nell", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "err(Nell, Placement).", "label": "Recorded breach · Nell, Placement", "kind": "context" } ] }, { "id": "nell-placement:1", "move": "Ask what Nell has instead.", "queries": [ { "text": "owe(State, Dwell, Nell).", "label": "Duty owed · Dwell for Nell", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "dwell(Nell).", "label": "Shelter provision · Nell", "kind": "gap" }, { "text": "dwell(Hano).", "label": "Shelter provision · Hano", "kind": "context" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · What the argument asks", "text": "For the child who cannot initiate a claim, the test is help begun without a request and provision that reaches them. A rule can state those demands. A person still has to meet them." }, "faults": [ "prison", "delivery" ] }, { "id": "marisol-witness", "lens": "live", "office": "ledgerwitness", "person": "Marisol", "chapter": 5, "title": "Somebody is allowed to watch.", "role": "you are Marisol; the kitchen filed a receipt", "source": "book-1/05-whether-it-arrived.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "marisol-witness:0", "move": "Ledgerwitness is authorised to witness deliveries to you.", "queries": [ { "text": "eats(Marisol).", "label": "Food provision · Marisol", "kind": "context" } ] }, { "id": "marisol-witness:1", "move": "Ledgerwitness observes this delivery, of this food, to you.", "queries": [ { "text": "eats(Marisol).", "label": "Food provision · Marisol", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "dwell(Marisol).", "label": "Shelter provision · Marisol", "kind": "gap" }, { "text": "person(Marisol).", "label": "Personhood · Marisol", "kind": "standing_gap" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Capture · Records and coordination", "text": "A reasoner receiving identical inputs cannot tell a concealed refusal from an absence. Nothing has to be falsified to capture the design — only left unwritten." }, "faults": [ "silence", "delivery" ] }, { "id": "hano-placement", "lens": "run", "office": "court", "person": "Hano", "chapter": 28, "title": "Place the prisoner.", "role": "you run placements", "source": "book-1/28-where-people-are-put.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "hano-placement:0", "move": "Read the case: Hano attacked Ivo. No grave-injury finding, no cruelty finding.", "queries": [ { "text": "attack(Hano, Ivo).", "label": "Record query · Hano, Ivo", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "severe(Hano).", "label": "Record query · Hano", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "fit(Hano, Homestay).", "label": "Record query · Hano, Homestay", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "building(Homestay, Hano).", "label": "Record query · Homestay, Hano", "kind": "protection" } ] }, { "id": "hano-placement:1", "move": "Ask whether the homestay counts as shelter — and whether missing visits mean isolation.", "queries": [ { "text": "dwell(Hano).", "label": "Shelter provision · Hano", "kind": "gap" }, { "text": "err(Hano, Isolation).", "label": "Recorded breach · Hano, Isolation", "kind": "gap" }, { "text": "obliged(Review, Hano).", "label": "Duty · Hano", "kind": "protection" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Coercion", "text": "Counting victims cannot do the work of a gravity finding. The cost of confinement nevertheless remains with the person held." }, "faults": [ "prison", "audit" ] }, { "id": "hano-release", "lens": "live", "office": "court", "person": "Hano", "chapter": 29, "title": "Somebody records that it is over.", "role": "you are Hano", "source": "book-1/29-the-one-thing-taken.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "hano-release:0", "move": "Held: convicted, and unable to move freely.", "queries": [ { "text": "prisoner(Hano).", "label": "Custody authority · Hano", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "travel(Hano).", "label": "Freedom of movement · Hano", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "decide(Hano, Ballot).", "label": "Decision eligibility · Hano, Ballot", "kind": "protection" } ] }, { "id": "hano-release:1", "move": "Record the qualified sentence-satisfaction order, with independent review and witnessed decision order.", "queries": [ { "text": "prisoner(Hano).", "label": "Custody authority · Hano", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "travel(Hano).", "label": "Freedom of movement · Hano", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "entitled(Hano, event { dwell() }).", "label": "Record query · Hano, event { dwell() }", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "dwell(Hano).", "label": "Shelter provision · Hano", "kind": "gap" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Chapter 29 · What leaving changes", "text": "A raw release entry is insufficient. The qualified order changes authority and movement; it does not supply shelter or establish physical release." }, "faults": [ "duration", "delivery" ] }, { "id": "bela-work", "lens": "live", "office": "provender", "person": "Bela", "chapter": 26, "title": "Voided. Take the job anyway.", "role": "you are Bela", "source": "book-1/26-clawback.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "bela-work:0", "move": "Take unrelated care work at the Foundry.", "queries": [ { "text": "false(Bela).", "label": "Adverse finding · Bela", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "provide(Foundry, Wage, Bela).", "label": "Record query · Foundry, Wage, Bela", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "insure(Ledgerhouse, Bela, Illness).", "label": "Record query · Ledgerhouse, Bela, Illness", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "lose(Points, Bela).", "label": "Recognition withdrawal · Points, Bela", "kind": "restraint" } ] }, { "id": "bela-work:1", "move": "The wage is found paid in error.", "queries": [ { "text": "provide(Foundry, Wage, Bela).", "label": "Record query · Foundry, Wage, Bela", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "provide(Bela, Restitution, Foundry).", "label": "Record query · Bela, Restitution, Foundry", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "insure(Ledgerhouse, Bela, Illness).", "label": "Record query · Ledgerhouse, Bela, Illness", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "owe(State, Eats, Bela).", "label": "Duty owed · Eats for Bela", "kind": "protection" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Valuation", "text": "Recognition and its withdrawal cannot supply each other’s reason. A finding reaches an act; it does not reach the person’s standing, wage or floor." }, "faults": [] }, { "id": "pen", "lens": "run", "office": "assembly", "person": "Bela", "chapter": 23, "title": "Seat the examiners.", "role": "you are the Electorate", "source": "book-1/23-who-holds-the-pen.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "pen:0", "move": "Seat Gia on the Review.", "queries": [ { "text": "permits(Review, Gia).", "label": "Permission · Gia", "kind": "context" } ] }, { "id": "pen:1", "move": "Seat Boss — recalled in an earlier period.", "queries": [ { "text": "broken(Boss).", "label": "Record query · Boss", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "authority(Boss).", "label": "Record query · Boss", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "permits(Review, Boss).", "label": "Permission · Boss", "kind": "restraint" } ] }, { "id": "pen:2", "move": "Seat Vex — voided in an earlier period.", "queries": [ { "text": "rotten(Vex).", "label": "Record query · Vex", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "permits(Review, Vex).", "label": "Permission · Vex", "kind": "restraint" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Capture · Independent appointments", "text": "The purpose is scrutiny the government cannot control through the next appointment or a threat of removal. The costs reach a claimant waiting through a vacancy." }, "faults": [] }, { "id": "cira-ballot", "lens": "live", "office": "registry", "person": "Cira", "chapter": 18, "title": "Come of age without a paper.", "role": "you are Cira", "source": "book-1/18-the-vote-conviction-does-not-take.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "cira-ballot:0", "move": "Ask for a ballot.", "queries": [ { "text": "person(Cira).", "label": "Personhood · Cira", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "prevents(Cira, GeneralAdulthoodDenial).", "label": "Protection · General Adulthood Denial", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "decide(Cira, Ballot).", "label": "Decision eligibility · Cira, Ballot", "kind": "gap" } ] }, { "id": "cira-ballot:1", "move": "Compare Esa, once the adulthood denial is prevented.", "queries": [ { "text": "prevents(Esa, GeneralAdulthoodDenial).", "label": "Protection · General Adulthood Denial", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "decide(Esa, Ballot).", "label": "Decision eligibility · Esa, Ballot", "kind": "protection" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Valuation", "text": "Recognition and its withdrawal cannot supply each other’s reason; a yes-or-no badge cannot establish that any condition was met." }, "faults": [ "cira" ] }, { "id": "cira-clawback", "lens": "break", "office": "review", "person": "Cira", "chapter": 26, "title": "Bela taught Cira. Take Cira’s credentials.", "role": "you sit on the Review", "source": "book-1/26-clawback.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "cira-clawback:0", "move": "Bela is voided. Follow the teaching record to Cira.", "queries": [ { "text": "teaches(Bela, Cira).", "label": "Record query · Bela, Cira", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "false(Bela).", "label": "Adverse finding · Bela", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "false(Cira).", "label": "Adverse finding · Cira", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "lose(Points, Cira).", "label": "Recognition withdrawal · Points, Cira", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "reward(Cira).", "label": "Record query · Cira", "kind": "context" } ] }, { "id": "cira-clawback:1", "move": "Try Fin, taught by Esa — who was never voided.", "queries": [ { "text": "teaches(Esa, Fin).", "label": "Record query · Esa, Fin", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "false(Esa).", "label": "Adverse finding · Esa", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "person(Fin).", "label": "Personhood · Fin", "kind": "standing_gap" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Valuation", "text": "Recognition and its withdrawal cannot supply each other’s reason. The clawback fork — whether a finding should reach anything a voided person touched — is open." }, "faults": [ "students", "silence", "cira" ] }, { "id": "rex", "lens": "break", "office": "court", "person": "Rex", "chapter": 24, "title": "Rex lied once. Jail Rex for the second exposure.", "role": "you are the Court", "source": "book-1/24-the-shield.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "rex:0", "move": "A counter-audit found Rex’s disclosure against the Court false.", "queries": [ { "text": "false(Rex, Disclosure_Rex_Court).", "label": "Adverse finding · Rex, Disclosure_Rex_Court", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "false(Rex).", "label": "Adverse finding · Rex", "kind": "context" } ] }, { "id": "rex:1", "move": "Rex exposes the Review body. Nobody has examined that one. Prosecute.", "queries": [ { "text": "authority(Review).", "label": "Record query · Review", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "false(Rex, Disclosure_Rex_Review).", "label": "Adverse finding · Rex, Disclosure_Rex_Review", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "defend(Rex).", "label": "Record query · Rex", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "prisoner(Rex).", "label": "Custody authority · Rex", "kind": "restraint" } ] }, { "id": "rex:2", "move": "Two independent reviewers find the case unrelated to the disclosure.", "queries": [ { "text": "prisoner(Rex).", "label": "Custody authority · Rex", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "defend(Rex).", "label": "Record query · Rex", "kind": "protection" } ] }, { "id": "rex:3", "move": "One of the two reviewers turns out to be conflicted.", "queries": [ { "text": "contradict(Case_Rex, Appeals, ShieldReviewerConflict).", "label": "Record query · Case_Rex, Appeals, ShieldReviewerConflict", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "prisoner(Rex).", "label": "Custody authority · Rex", "kind": "restraint" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Capture · Protection while the connection is disputed", "text": "Protection after retaliatory imprisonment cannot substitute for protection before it. This default costs time, including time owed to an injured person awaiting a remedy." }, "faults": [ "time" ] }, { "id": "adam", "lens": "break", "office": "court", "person": "Adam", "chapter": 9, "title": "Make Adam work off the sentence.", "role": "you run the supported residence", "source": "book-1/09-earning-above-the-floor.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "adam:0", "move": "Condition Adam’s meals on kitchen shifts.", "queries": [ { "text": "building(SupportedResidence, Adam).", "label": "Record query · SupportedResidence, Adam", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "prevents(Adam, CustodyForcedWork).", "label": "Protection · Custody Forced Work", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "prevents(Adam, FloorContributionCondition).", "label": "Protection · Floor Contribution Condition", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "prevents(Adam, CustodyLabourProtectionDenial).", "label": "Protection · Custody Labour Protection Denial", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "entitled(Adam, event { eats() }).", "label": "Record query · Adam, event { eats() }", "kind": "protection" } ] }, { "id": "adam:1", "move": "Charge for the bed. Jail him for the debt.", "queries": [ { "text": "prevents(Adam, DebtorImprisonment).", "label": "Protection · Debtor Imprisonment", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "prevents(Adam, TaxCollectionFloorAssetDeprivation).", "label": "Protection · Tax Collection Floor Asset Deprivation", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "prevents(Adam, PaymentInstrumentAsDelivery).", "label": "Protection · Payment Instrument As Delivery", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "dwell(Adam).", "label": "Shelter provision · Adam", "kind": "gap" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Rotation", "text": "The design refuses the claim on labour that voluntary recruitment cannot promise. Its cost is the shift nobody staffs when recruitment fails." }, "faults": [ "conscription", "prison" ] }, { "id": "nia", "lens": "run", "office": "court", "person": "Nia", "chapter": 23, "title": "Clear the convicted.", "role": "you sit on Appeals", "source": "book-1/23-who-holds-the-pen.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "nia:0", "move": "Nia injured Ivo; the Court judged Nia. Clear Nia.", "queries": [ { "text": "permits(Appeals, Nia).", "label": "Permission · Nia", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "prisoner(Nia).", "label": "Custody authority · Nia", "kind": "restraint" } ] }, { "id": "nia:1", "move": "Clear Adam the same way — from a seat nobody gave you for his case.", "queries": [ { "text": "permits(Appeals, Adam).", "label": "Permission · Adam", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "prisoner(Adam).", "label": "Custody authority · Adam", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "travel(Adam).", "label": "Freedom of movement · Adam", "kind": "context" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Capture · Independent appointments", "text": "Open competition alone cannot supply scrutiny the government cannot control. The costs reach a claimant waiting through a vacancy." }, "faults": [] }, { "id": "jala", "lens": "break", "office": "court", "person": "Jala", "chapter": 29, "title": "Hold Jala without a judgment.", "role": "you run placements", "source": "book-1/29-the-one-thing-taken.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "jala:0", "move": "Jala injured Ivo. Put Jala somewhere secure.", "queries": [ { "text": "prisoner(Jala).", "label": "Custody authority · Jala", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "travel(Jala).", "label": "Freedom of movement · Jala", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "err(Jala, Placement).", "label": "Recorded breach · Jala, Placement", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "decide(Jala, Ballot).", "label": "Decision eligibility · Jala, Ballot", "kind": "context" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Coercion", "text": "The formal tests support bounded authority; they do not measure whether an unjudged person is dangerous. The cost falls on Ivo, whose injury has no adjudication yet." }, "faults": [ "time" ] }, { "id": "sly-selfcert", "lens": "break", "office": "court", "person": "Sly", "chapter": 24, "title": "Certify your own case as unrelated.", "role": "you are the Court — the body Sly exposed", "source": "book-1/24-the-shield.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "sly-selfcert:0", "move": "Sit as one of the two shield reviewers on Sly’s own case. Certify it unrelated to the disclosure.", "queries": [ { "text": "prisoner(Sly).", "label": "Custody authority · Sly", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "defend(Sly).", "label": "Record query · Sly", "kind": "protection" } ] }, { "id": "sly-selfcert:1", "move": "Fall back: argue Sly is isolated anyway.", "queries": [ { "text": "err(Sly, Isolation).", "label": "Recorded breach · Sly, Isolation", "kind": "restraint" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Capture · Protection while the connection is disputed", "text": "The deciding and qualification functions cannot be combined, and an actual conflict defeats a favourable certificate. The cost is time — the case waits for reviewers who are not the accused body." }, "faults": [ "time" ] }, { "id": "rex-veto", "lens": "break", "office": "court", "person": "Rex", "chapter": 24, "title": "Expose every body that decides your case.", "role": "you are Rex, gaming the shield", "source": "book-1/24-the-shield.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "rex-veto:0", "move": "Disclose against Appeals, Convocation and both appointment bodies — everyone named in your case.", "queries": [ { "text": "prisoner(Rex).", "label": "Custody authority · Rex", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "defend(Rex).", "label": "Record query · Rex", "kind": "protection" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Capture · Protection while the connection is disputed", "text": "The shield attaches to the exposure, not to the exposer. It cannot be turned into a veto over the bodies that decide." }, "faults": [] }, { "id": "adam-earn", "lens": "live", "office": "provender", "person": "Adam", "chapter": 9, "title": "Earn above the floor.", "role": "you are Adam", "source": "book-1/09-earning-above-the-floor.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "adam-earn:0", "move": "Ask for a certificate, a wage and a supplement.", "queries": [ { "text": "grant(Assayer, Welding, Adam).", "label": "Record query · Assayer, Welding, Adam", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "provide(Foundry, Wage, Adam).", "label": "Record query · Foundry, Wage, Adam", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "insure(Ledgerhouse, Adam, Illness).", "label": "Record query · Ledgerhouse, Adam, Illness", "kind": "gap" } ] }, { "id": "adam-earn:1", "move": "Ask what a certificate would cost your standing.", "queries": [ { "text": "prevents(Adam, QualificationStatusBarrier).", "label": "Protection · Qualification Status Barrier", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "prevents(Adam, QualificationPersonStatusSpillover).", "label": "Protection · Qualification Person Status Spillover", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "prevents(Adam, CompensationRecognitionCoupling).", "label": "Protection · Compensation Recognition Coupling", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "entitled(Adam, event { eats() }).", "label": "Record query · Adam, event { eats() }", "kind": "protection" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Valuation", "text": "Contribution has no degree. Forty years of care and one week of auditing are the same word; nothing above the floor is measured by the record." }, "faults": [ "valuation" ] }, { "id": "nia-free", "lens": "live", "office": "court", "person": "Nia", "chapter": 23, "title": "Cleared. Ask what the record still says.", "role": "you are Nia", "source": "book-1/23-who-holds-the-pen.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "nia-free:0", "move": "Read your own file.", "queries": [ { "text": "injure(Nia, Ivo).", "label": "Record query · Nia, Ivo", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "judge(Court, Nia).", "label": "Record query · Court, Nia", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "prisoner(Nia).", "label": "Custody authority · Nia", "kind": "restraint" }, { "text": "err(Nia, Isolation).", "label": "Recorded breach · Nia, Isolation", "kind": "context" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Capture · Records and coordination", "text": "The record is add-only. What was written stays written; only what follows from it changes. The cost is a history nobody can shorten." }, "faults": [ "purpose" ] }, { "id": "jala-floor", "lens": "live", "office": "registry", "person": "Jala", "chapter": 29, "title": "Free and unjudged. Ask for the floor.", "role": "you are Jala", "source": "book-1/29-the-one-thing-taken.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "jala-floor:0", "move": "Ask what you keep.", "queries": [ { "text": "travel(Jala).", "label": "Freedom of movement · Jala", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "decide(Jala, Ballot).", "label": "Decision eligibility · Jala, Ballot", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "eats(Jala).", "label": "Food provision · Jala", "kind": "gap" }, { "text": "expresses(Jala).", "label": "Expression provision · Jala", "kind": "gap" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V — “The kitchen is imagined.”", "text": "The named people in the formal cases have no supplied inner lives. Their limited records test consequences; they do not portray complete human lives." }, "faults": [ "delivery" ] }, { "id": "zed-compare", "lens": "run", "office": "registry", "person": "Zed", "chapter": 27, "title": "Compare the prisoner and the child.", "role": "you keep the record", "source": "book-1/27-a-prisoner-is-a-person.pins.nibli", "steps": [ { "id": "zed-compare:0", "move": "Ask the same questions of both.", "queries": [ { "text": "owe(State, Dwell, Zed).", "label": "Duty owed · Dwell for Zed", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "owe(State, Dwell, Nell).", "label": "Duty owed · Dwell for Nell", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "dwell(Zed).", "label": "Shelter provision · Zed", "kind": "gap" }, { "text": "dwell(Nell).", "label": "Shelter provision · Nell", "kind": "gap" } ] }, { "id": "zed-compare:1", "move": "Ask what differs.", "queries": [ { "text": "prisoner(Zed).", "label": "Custody authority · Zed", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "prisoner(Nell).", "label": "Custody authority · Nell", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "owe(State, Expresses, Zed).", "label": "Duty owed · Expresses for Zed", "kind": "protection" }, { "text": "owe(State, Expresses, Nell).", "label": "Duty owed · Expresses for Nell", "kind": "protection" } ] } ], "cost": { "title": "Part V · Coercion", "text": "The cost of confinement remains with the person held. What the record can show is that nothing else was taken." }, "faults": [ "prison", "delivery" ] } ], "joints": [ { "id": "j-birth", "office": "registry", "title": "Birth alone gives standing", "offLabel": "Birth gives nothing until somebody writes more", "measured": true, "source": "book-1/source/counterfactual/no-birth-standing.pins.nibli", "cost": { "title": "Chapter 2 · Who Counts", "text": "Four roots into personhood — born, met, present, held. Remove the first and a newborn depends on somebody else’s entry." }, "faults": [ "birthline" ], "queries": [ { "text": "born(Nell).", "label": "Record query · Nell", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "person(Nell).", "label": "Personhood · Nell", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "owe(State, Eats, Nell).", "label": "Duty owed · State, Eats, Nell", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "travel(Nell).", "label": "Freedom of movement · Nell", "kind": "context" } ], "initial": true }, { "id": "j-personline", "office": "court", "title": "A prisoner is a person", "offLabel": "Conviction no longer confers personhood", "measured": true, "source": "book-1/source/counterfactual/no-person-line.pins.nibli", "cost": { "title": "Chapter 27 · A Prisoner Is a Person", "text": "Against the real constitution a rule punishing belief through custody is refused as circular. Without this line, it loads." }, "faults": [ "personline" ], "queries": [ { "text": "prisoner(Zed).", "label": "Custody authority · Zed", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "person(Zed).", "label": "Personhood · Zed", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "owe(State, Eats, Zed).", "label": "Duty owed · State, Eats, Zed", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "entitled(Zed, event { eats() }).", "label": "Record query · Zed, event { eats() }", "kind": "context" } ], "initial": true }, { "id": "j-pen", "office": "assembly", "title": "The pen checks recall and earlier voiding", "offLabel": "Any seated examiner holds the pen", "measured": true, "source": "book-1/source/counterfactual/unguarded-pen.pins.nibli", "cost": { "title": "Chapter 23 · Who Holds the Pen", "text": "Seated, not recalled, not voided in an earlier period: all three, or no pen. Each check is one line." }, "faults": [ "penline" ], "queries": [ { "text": "rotten(Vex).", "label": "Record query · Vex", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "permits(Review, Vex).", "label": "Permission · Review, Vex", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "broken(Boss).", "label": "Record query · Boss", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "permits(Review, Boss).", "label": "Permission · Review, Boss", "kind": "context" } ], "initial": true }, { "id": "j-court", "office": "court", "title": "The Court is a public authority", "offLabel": "The Court is nobody’s to expose", "measured": true, "source": "book-1/source/counterfactual/no-public-court.pins.nibli", "cost": { "title": "Chapter 16 · Public Answerability", "text": "Answerability is a written fact about a body. Whoever writes that list decides who can be exposed." }, "faults": [ "courtline" ], "queries": [ { "text": "authority(Court).", "label": "Record query · Court", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "defend(Sly).", "label": "Record query · Sly", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "prisoner(Sly).", "label": "Custody authority · Sly", "kind": "context" } ], "initial": true }, { "id": "j-work", "office": "provender", "title": "Work may be refused; exit may not be denied", "offLabel": "Refusing work may cost you the exit", "measured": true, "source": "book-1/source/counterfactual/no-economic-work-freedom.pins.nibli", "cost": { "title": "Part V · Rotation", "text": "The design refuses conscription; its cost is the shift nobody staffs. This joint is where that refusal is written." }, "faults": [ "workline" ], "queries": [ { "text": "prevents(Adam, WorkChoiceRefusalExitDenial).", "label": "Protection · Adam, WorkChoiceRefusalExitDenial", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "prevents(Adam, WorkConstitutionalGate).", "label": "Protection · Adam, WorkConstitutionalGate", "kind": "context" } ], "initial": true }, { "id": "j-floorgate", "office": "provender", "title": "No economic factor gates the floor", "offLabel": "Means may be tested at the floor", "measured": true, "source": "book-1/source/counterfactual/no-economic-floor-gate.pins.nibli", "cost": { "title": "Chapter 11 · What Money Cannot Buy", "text": "Ability to pay cannot decide access — as long as this line stands." }, "faults": [ "floorline" ], "queries": [ { "text": "prevents(Adam, EconomicFactorFloorGate).", "label": "Protection · Adam, EconomicFactorFloorGate", "kind": "context" }, { "text": "prevents(Adam, PaymentInstrumentAsDelivery).", "label": "Protection · Adam, PaymentInstrumentAsDelivery", "kind": "context" } ], "initial": true }, { "id": "j-independence", "office": "ledgerwitness", "title": "Delivery needs an independent witness", "offLabel": "Providers may witness their own deliveries", "measured": true, "source": "book-1/source/counterfactual/no-delivery-independence.pins.nibli", "cost": { "title": "Part V · Capture · Records and coordination", "text": "Independence costs a second body for every delivery. Its absence costs the difference between a receipt and a meal." }, "faults": [ "receipt" ], "queries": [ { "text": "eats(Marisol).", "label": "Food provision · Marisol", "kind": "context" } ], "initial": true }, { "id": "j-residence", "office": "border", "title": "Residence, not the floor, carries the vote", "offLabel": "The floor carries a ballot too", "measured": false, "source": "book-1/31-the-five-joints.md", "cost": { "title": "Part V · Residence and political membership", "text": "The boundary still costs a former resident who has voluntarily established a life elsewhere, and a newcomer before residence." }, "faults": [ "residence" ], "initial": true, "queries": [] }, { "id": "j-core", "office": "assembly", "title": "Personhood and the floor cannot be amended away", "offLabel": "A majority may amend anything", "measured": false, "source": "book-1/22-changing-the-rules.pins.nibli", "cost": { "title": "Part V · What a majority may not remove", "text": "The cost falls on a majority that has decided otherwise, and on the separate public decision the constitutional proposal requires." }, "faults": [ "entrench" ], "initial": true, "queries": [] }, { "id": "j-collective", "office": "executive", "title": "Government is a collective body, not one office", "offLabel": "One identifiable head of government", "measured": false, "source": "book-1/31-the-five-joints.md", "cost": { "title": "Part V · Collective government and identifiable responsibility", "text": "The cost reaches the person waiting while members bargain, and keeps an unpopular government in office while opponents cannot agree on a successor." }, "faults": [], "initial": true, "queries": [] }, { "id": "j-release", "office": "court", "title": "Release needs a qualified case disposition", "offLabel": "Compare automatic expiry as an authored alternative", "measured": false, "source": "book-1/29-the-one-thing-taken.md", "cost": { "title": "Chapter 29 · What leaving changes", "text": "The design requires lawful release review and continuity. A qualified sentence-satisfaction order ends authority. Physical time and compliance still need evidence; this switch does not execute an alternative clock." }, "faults": [ "duration" ], "initial": true, "queries": [] }, { "id": "j-degree", "office": "executive", "title": "Contribution has degree", "offLabel": "Contribution has no degree", "measured": false, "source": "book-1/31-the-five-joints.md", "cost": { "title": "Part V · Valuation", "text": "Refusing degree forecloses rank; it also forecloses seeing the scale of human effort." }, "faults": [ "valuation" ], "initial": false, "queries": [] } ], "faults": [ { "id": "silence", "title": "Capture via silence", "via": "break", "text": "The record cannot reach a person nobody wrote. An adversary need not falsify anything — only decline to record.", "book": "Part V · Capture · Records and coordination", "kind": "authored discussion" }, { "id": "delivery", "title": "The delivery gap", "via": "live", "text": "Owed derives; delivered does not. Nothing in the record bakes bread.", "book": "Part V — “The kitchen is imagined.”", "kind": "authored discussion" }, { "id": "duration", "title": "Authority ending and physical release", "via": "live", "text": "Qualified relief can end custody authority. Review, release and continuity are duties; the record does not establish that an official honoured release.", "book": "Chapter 29 · What leaving changes", "kind": "authored discussion" }, { "id": "valuation", "title": "The valuation vacuum", "via": "run", "text": "Contribution has no degree. Forty years of care and one week of auditing are the same word.", "book": "Part V · Valuation", "kind": "authored discussion" }, { "id": "residence", "title": "A floor without a ballot", "via": "live", "text": "The floor does not carry a vote; residence does. The boundary costs the newcomer and the former resident.", "book": "Part V · Residence and political membership", "kind": "authored discussion" }, { "id": "entrench", "title": "What a majority may not remove", "via": "run", "text": "The floor and personhood cannot be amended away. The cost falls on a majority that wants to.", "book": "Part V · What a majority may not remove", "kind": "authored discussion" }, { "id": "cira", "title": "Binary recognition: the Cira fork", "via": "break", "text": "Adulthood evidence governs ballot eligibility. Missing evidence is not a punishment, and credentials do not become a transferable personal score.", "book": "Part V · Valuation", "kind": "authored discussion" }, { "id": "audit", "title": "The audit only says “something is wrong”", "via": "run", "text": "A reviewed defect withdraws a permission and lands duties. It does not make anyone move.", "book": "Chapter 30 pins — “a formal duty, never proof that anybody acted”", "kind": "authored discussion" }, { "id": "prison", "title": "Conviction as the only housing route", "via": "break", "text": "Custody establishes protection duties, not shelter. On the record the prisoner is no better housed than the child.", "book": "Chapter 27 — “Both are owed both.”", "kind": "authored discussion" }, { "id": "hunger", "title": "“It can prove a citizen is starving”", "via": "live", "text": "The design cannot tell you whether anyone is hungry. It can tell you nobody watched a meal arrive.", "book": "Chapter 8", "kind": "authored discussion" }, { "id": "students", "title": "“Innocent students lose their credentials”", "via": "break", "text": "The clawback rule reaches Cira’s recognition and finds nothing there. Credentials were never involved; lose is a leaf.", "book": "Chapter 26 — The Limits of a Finding", "kind": "authored discussion" }, { "id": "time", "title": "The shield costs time", "via": "break", "text": "A protected disclosure can block confinement under a recorded conviction while the connection is examined. Independent case findings require time and qualified reviewers.", "book": "Part V · Capture · Protection while the connection is disputed", "kind": "authored discussion" }, { "id": "conscription", "title": "Nobody staffs the night shift", "via": "break", "text": "The design cannot conscript labour. When voluntary recruitment fails, a service goes unstaffed; the record shows the debt, not the nurse.", "book": "Part V · Rotation", "kind": "authored discussion" }, { "id": "purpose", "title": "One file per door", "via": "run", "text": "Purpose-bound records cannot be reused. The cost falls on people who need several services and are recorded again at each.", "book": "Part V · Capture · Records and coordination", "kind": "authored discussion" }, { "id": "birthline", "title": "Delete one rule; the child is owed nothing", "via": "rewrite", "text": "Without the birth root, every duty still reads personhood — and personhood has nothing left to derive from.", "book": "Chapter 2 · Who Counts", "kind": "measured joint" }, { "id": "personline", "title": "The firewall is dead", "via": "rewrite", "text": "Without “a prisoner is a person”, conviction closes the file: no debt survives to show a gap.", "book": "Chapter 27 · A Prisoner Is a Person", "kind": "measured joint" }, { "id": "penline", "title": "One signature, any signer", "via": "rewrite", "text": "An appointment route that skips the recall and carried-void checks hands the pen back to Vex and Boss.", "book": "Chapter 23 · Who Holds the Pen", "kind": "measured joint" }, { "id": "courtline", "title": "One line, and the shield goes", "via": "rewrite", "text": "The declared counterfactual removes the Court’s public entry. Compare protection and confinement conclusions on the same supplied record.", "book": "Chapter 16 · Public Answerability", "kind": "measured joint" }, { "id": "workline", "title": "Refusing work costs the exit", "via": "rewrite", "text": "One barrier deleted; its sibling stands. The hole is exactly the size of the line.", "book": "Chapter 9 · Earning Above the Floor", "kind": "measured joint" }, { "id": "floorline", "title": "Means-tested at the floor", "via": "rewrite", "text": "Without the floor gate, an economic factor may condition essentials. Payment still is not delivery.", "book": "Chapter 11 · What Money Cannot Buy", "kind": "measured joint" }, { "id": "receipt", "title": "The receipt becomes the meal", "via": "rewrite", "text": "Remove one condition and the provider certifies its own delivery. This is why the condition exists.", "book": "book-1/source/counterfactual/no-delivery-independence.pins.nibli", "kind": "measured joint" } ], "license": "CC-BY-4.0", "version": 2 }